Vassilia Orfanou, PhD, Post-Doc
Writes for the Headline Diplomat eMagazine, LUDCI.eu
This intriguing question regarding the definition of a woman delves into a realm where certainty fades and complexity arises. In an era marked by shifting perspectives on gender identity, the concept of womanhood has become a multifaceted and contentious topic. What was once a straightforward understanding rooted in biological factors has given way to a nuanced exploration of gender, feelings, and societal constructs.
The growing uncertainty surrounding the question stems from the evolving understanding of gender roles and identities. Can someone identify as a woman based solely on their internal sense of self, regardless of their assigned sex at birth? Are gender roles merely societal constructs, subject to interpretation and personal experiences? These inquiries challenge deeply ingrained beliefs and force a reassessment of what it truly means to be a woman.
In the past, the prevailing understanding was anchored in biology. Being a woman was associated with the biological characteristics and functions specific to females. However, prominent experts now emphasize that biology alone does not define womanhood. This shift in perspective, which gained momentum in 2022, has brought the question to the forefront of public discourse, surprising many who had previously taken the answer for granted.
An intriguing incident occurred during the confirmation hearings for a U.S. Supreme Court nominee, Ketanji Brown Jackson, when she declined to provide a definitive definition of a woman, stating her lack of expertise in biology. This raises the intriguing notion that perhaps only biologists possess the authority to answer such a question. Yet, even within the scientific community, unease arises when attempting to define womanhood in a way that excludes individuals who identify as women but may not align with biological categorizations. The fear of being deemed politically incorrect and the potential consequences for reputation and career can create an atmosphere of reluctance to engage in this topic openly.
In the quest for understanding, political commentator and provocateur Matt Walsh tackles this intricate subject matter in his documentary, “What Is A Woman.” Through thought-provoking interviews with psychologists, medical experts, and women from diverse backgrounds, Walsh seeks clear explanations that transcend vague and evasive responses.
He pushes the boundaries of conventional thinking, challenging interviewees to articulate the distinction between biological sex and gender identity. This unyielding pursuit of truth often elicits discomfort and reveals the complexities inherent in addressing such a deeply personal and socially significant matter.
The documentary that was based on highlights that can be checked in the following link expands its scope by exploring the experiences of women who have encountered transgender athletes in competitive settings. These women share their perspectives, voicing concerns about fairness and the potential impact on their achievements and opportunities. Their stories shed light on the intricate balance between inclusivity and maintaining a level playing field in various domains.
Another poignant narrative highlighted in the film revolves around Robert Hoogland, a Canadian father who found himself embroiled in a harrowing battle over his 14-year-old daughter’s gender identity. The legal system’s involvement, coupled with the administration of body-altering hormone-suppressing medication without parental consent, raises profound questions about autonomy, parental rights, and the power of the state in shaping personal identities.
Conclusion
Despite the myriad viewpoints presented throughout the documentary, “What Is A Woman” does not offer a definitive answer to the initial question. Instead, it invites viewers to grapple with the complexities and contradictions that emerge when trying to define and understand womanhood in a rapidly evolving social landscape. The film aims to provoke thoughtful consideration, challenging prevailing narratives and encouraging a deeper exploration of personal beliefs and societal norms.
It is worth noting that opinions on this topic tend to be strongly polarized, with individuals either aligning with Walsh’s perspective or vehemently opposing it. Consequently, those who hold unfavorable views of Walsh may be inclined to dismiss the film without engaging with its content.
Nevertheless, “What Is A Woman” serves as a catalyst for open dialogue, encouraging individuals to confront their own biases, critically analyze the subject matter, and seek a greater understanding of the complexities surrounding gender identity and womanhood in contemporary society.
Featured photo: Criativithy: https://www.pexels.com/el-gr/photo/1821095/
